Skip to content

Can anyone explain this to me?

July 19, 2012

The Mexican government has been working with the United States Department of  Agriculture to increase participation in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance  Program (SNAP), or food stamps.

USDA has an agreement with Mexico to promote American food assistance  programs, including food stamps, among Mexican Americans, Mexican nationals and  migrant communities in America.

“USDA and the government of Mexico have entered into a partnership to help  educate eligible Mexican nationals living in the United States about available  nutrition assistance,” the USDA explains in a brief paragraph on their “Reaching Low-Income Hispanics With Nutrition Assistance” web  page. “Mexico will help disseminate this information through its embassy and  network of approximately 50 consular offices.”

The partnership — which was signed by former USDA Secretary Ann M.  Veneman and Mexican Secretary of Foreign Affairs Luis Ernesto Derbez Bautista in  2004 — sees to it that the Mexican Embassy and Mexican consulates in America  provide USDA nutrition assistance program information to Mexican Americans,  Mexican nationals working in America and migrant communities in America. The  information is specifically focused on eligibility criteria and access.

The goal, for USDA, is to get rid of what they see as enrollment obstacles  and increase access among potentially eligible populations by working with arms  of the Mexican government in America. Benefits are not guaranteed or provided  under the program — the purpose is outreach and education.

Some of the materials the USDA encourages the Mexican  government to use to educate and promote the benefit programs are available free  online for order and download. A partial list of materials include English and  Spanish brochures titled “Five Easy Steps To Snap Benefits,” “How To Get Food  Help — A Consumer’s Guide to FNCS Programs,” “Ending Hunger Improving Nutrition  Combating Obesity,” and posters with slogans like “Food Stamps Make America  Stronger.”

When asked for details and to elaborate on the program, USDA stressed it was  established in 2004 and not meant for illegal immigrants.

“The partnership with the Mexican embassy was established in 2004,” a USDA  spokesman wrote The Daily Caller in an email. “USDA does not perform outreach to  immigrants that are undocumented, and therefore not eligible for SNAP.” (RELATED: USDA  buckles, removes Spanish food stamp soap operas from website)

Alabama Republican Sen. Jeff Sessions, who has been pushing for reform of  SNAP, sent a letter to Secretary of Agriculture Tom  Vilsack on Wednesday demanding more answers and documents pertaining to the  partnership.

The agency has yet to supply documents and information requested by Sessions’ Senate Budget Committee staff, including the Memorandums of Understanding  between USDA and the Mexican government regarding the food assistance  partnership.

In an interview with TheDC, Sessions explained that the little-known  partnership raises questions not just about where tax money is going, but about  America’s immigration policy.

“It’s a very disturbing policy, gone on for some years, and it raises very  serious questions about American immigration policy as well as fiscal policy,” Session said. “Let’s get back to the fundamentals. What happened with the ‘96  welfare reform was to say that if want to you come to America you come legally,  you assert you’re not coming for welfare benefits but you’re coming to work or  otherwise be independent. There is no logic behind an immigration policy that  would encourage immigrants who can’t successfully operate within this  society.”

According to Sessions, immigrants who come to America should be able to  operate successfully without the aid of government.

“An immigration policy should seek to bring people to the United States who  will be able to function independently without government subsidies,” he  explained. “We’ve got millions of people that want to come here, millions of  people who would be able to perform without a subsidy, so we need to be  selecting those people.”

Sessions isn’t simply concerned that the USDA has eschewed transparency with  their Mexican partnership or that legal immigrants are encouraged to get on the  government’s handout rolls — he is also worried about the lack of protections  against undocumented immigrants receiving benefits for which they are not  qualified.

As the senator detailed in his letter to Vilsack, and the USDA’s 2011 Guidance on Non-Citizen Eligibility for SNAP explains, although undocumented immigrants are usually not eligible to  enroll in SNAP, illegals may enroll their eligible children.

It is up to the states to determine if applicants or households are qualified  aliens. In some circumstances, SNAP benefits can be conferred upon people who  merely state, upon penalty of perjury, that they are in the country legally.

“Applicants need only attest that they are citizens of the United States, and  the state must accept that attestation as conclusive,” Sessions explained in his  letter. “Some states currently voluntarily participate in the Systematic Alien  Verification for Entitlements (SAVE) program, which allows administrators to run  a simple check to determine if non-citizen applicants are eligible for benefits.  States that do not use SAVE to verify alien status may simply accept the  applicant’s attestation of legal status as a substitute for verification, or,  alternately, may accept submitted documents without checking their  veracity.”

Sessions offered an amendment to the Senate version of the 2012 farm bill  last month which would have required the government to use SAVE — a program  similar to E-Verify — to ensure SNAP recipients are in the country legally. The  amendment was not brought to the floor for a vote.

According to Sessions’ office, the Congressional Budget Office was unable to  estimate how much money the SAVE amendment would have saved because the federal  government does not know how many ineligible illegal immigrants have accessed  SNAP.

Mexico is the only country with which USDA has a nutrition assistance  outreach partnership agreement.

Read more:


My comment:

The use of food stamps should be discouraged, not promoted.


From → Uncategorized

Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: